Bay Shore Housing Market Overview

Use data to learn how you can succeed as a homebuyer or seller in Bay Shore. Talk to a top real estate agent to see what local trends are driving the housing market in Bay Shore, NY.

Find an agent

Nearby homes for sale

The home at 180 NEWBROOK LN UNIT 27 BAY SHORE, NY

Listed 2 months ago

$2,800

180 NEWBROOK LN UNIT 27 BAY SHORE, NY

210

The home at 135 S PENATAQUIT AVE BAY SHORE, NY

Listed a month ago

$649,000

135 S PENATAQUIT AVE BAY SHORE, NY

320

Listed 3 months ago

$639,000

5 COTTAGE AVE BAY SHORE, NY

421,568

The home at 11 S SAXON AVE APT 4E BAY SHORE, NY

Listed 14 days ago

$2,995

11 S SAXON AVE APT 4E BAY SHORE, NY

220

The home at 11 S SAXON AVE APT 2D BAY SHORE, NY

Listed 2 months ago

$1,975

11 S SAXON AVE APT 2D BAY SHORE, NY

010

The home at 21 BRENTWOOD RD APT 27 BAY SHORE, NY

Listed 2 months ago

$2,450

21 BRENTWOOD RD APT 27 BAY SHORE, NY

110

The home at 25 N CLINTON AVE APT 1A BAY SHORE, NY

Listed a month ago

$2,390

25 N CLINTON AVE APT 1A BAY SHORE, NY

110

The home at 75 NEWBROOK LN UNIT 75 BAY SHORE, NY

Listed a month ago

$289,999

75 NEWBROOK LN UNIT 75 BAY SHORE, NY

11782

The home at 180 NEWBROOK LN UNIT 180 BAY SHORE, NY

Listed 2 months ago

$2,800

180 NEWBROOK LN UNIT 180 BAY SHORE, NY

210

The home at 241 W MAIN ST APT 10 BAY SHORE, NY

Listed 2 months ago

$2,180

241 W MAIN ST APT 10 BAY SHORE, NY

110

The home at 43 DORAL LN UNIT 43 BAY SHORE, NY

Listed 2 months ago

$639,990

43 DORAL LN UNIT 43 BAY SHORE, NY

321,758

The home at 94 4TH AVE UNIT 201 BAY SHORE, NY

Listed a month ago

$1,850

94 4TH AVE UNIT 201 BAY SHORE, NY

01400

Listed a month ago

$689,999

12 MAPLE CT BAY SHORE, NY

320

The home at 91 S CLINTON AVE APT 5D BAY SHORE, NY

Listed 2 months ago

$2,895

91 S CLINTON AVE APT 5D BAY SHORE, NY

220

The home at 92 S CLINTON AVE APT 4G BAY SHORE, NY

Listed 2 months ago

$2,350

92 S CLINTON AVE APT 4G BAY SHORE, NY

110

The home at 92 S CLINTON AVE APT 6C BAY SHORE, NY

Listed 2 months ago

$2,350

92 S CLINTON AVE APT 6C BAY SHORE, NY

110

The home at 21 BRENTWOOD RD APT 9 BAY SHORE, NY

Listed 2 months ago

$2,450

21 BRENTWOOD RD APT 9 BAY SHORE, NY

110

The home at 11 S SAXON AVE APT 3E BAY SHORE, NY

Listed a month ago

$2,995

11 S SAXON AVE APT 3E BAY SHORE, NY

210

Listed a month ago

$2,500

17 MARS RD BAY SHORE, NY

210

The home at 43 PINEBROOK PL BAY SHORE, NY

Listed 2 months ago

$2,200

43 PINEBROOK PL BAY SHORE, NY

110

The home at 241 W MAIN ST APT 8 BAY SHORE, NY

Listed 2 months ago

$2,180

241 W MAIN ST APT 8 BAY SHORE, NY

110

The home at 409 E MAIN ST APT 7 BAY SHORE, NY

Listed a month ago

$2,895

409 E MAIN ST APT 7 BAY SHORE, NY

220

Listed 2 months ago

$89,999

12 FERN AVE BAY SHORE, NY

210

The home at 64 S CLINTON AVE APT 2A BAY SHORE, NY

Listed 2 months ago

$2,365

64 S CLINTON AVE APT 2A BAY SHORE, NY

110

Listed 2 months ago

$2,800

180 NEWBROOK LN UNIT 27 BAY SHORE, NY

210

Listed a month ago

$649,000

135 S PENATAQUIT AVE BAY SHORE, NY

320

Listed 3 months ago

$639,000

5 COTTAGE AVE BAY SHORE, NY

421,568

Listed 14 days ago

$2,995

11 S SAXON AVE APT 4E BAY SHORE, NY

220

Listed 2 months ago

$1,975

11 S SAXON AVE APT 2D BAY SHORE, NY

010

Listed 2 months ago

$2,450

21 BRENTWOOD RD APT 27 BAY SHORE, NY

110

Check out some of our other resources for Bay Shore homeowners

Find Top Agents

The best agents sell your home more quickly and for more money.

Find my agent

Sell your house in Bay Shore fast

Find out what cash buyers are willing to pay for your home right now.

Get my offer

Find out what your home is worth

Get a free estimated value of your home in less than 2 minutes.

Get my estimate

When's the best time to sell your home in Bay Shore?

Use housing market data in Bay Shore to learn the best and worst months to sell your home.

Find out

Real estate commission in Bay Shore

Use this calculator and real estate agent commissions data to find out.

Find out

Advice from America’s Top Agents

Get the latest real estate tips and learn how to sell your home faster and for more money.

Compare Bay Shore to nearby housing markets

Norwalk

Active agents1,377
Days on market93
Median sale price$429,000

Explore housing markets similar to Bay Shore

Oak Park

Active agents1,390
Days on market51
Median sale price$147,000

Sterling

Active agents1,408
Days on market41
Median sale price$410,000

Atwater

Active agents784
Days on market60
Median sale price$277,000