What Is a Home Equity Investment? Unlock Cash With No Monthly Payments
- Published on
- 12 min read
-
Richard Haddad Executive EditorClose
Richard Haddad Executive EditorRichard Haddad is the executive editor of HomeLight.com. He works with an experienced content team that oversees the company’s blog featuring in-depth articles about the home buying and selling process, homeownership news, home care and design tips, and related real estate trends. Previously, he served as an editor and content producer for World Company, Gannett, and Western News & Info, where he also served as news director and director of internet operations.
When a homeowner needs fast access to cash for a life change or opportunity, their first thought may be to tap into their equity. But what if you can’t afford to make additional monthly payments on a traditional home equity loan, or your credit score won’t qualify for a cash-out refinance or line of credit? You may find the solution is a home equity investment.
A home equity investment (HEI) sharing agreement is a flexible alternative gaining traction among U.S. homeowners. It’s a creative option to battle high interest rates, monthly income limitations, or hurdles like low credit scores and stringent lending criteria.
HEIs can open a window to tap into your home’s value without the stress of monthly payments, but they come with some risks you’ll want to understand and weigh.
How Much Is Your Home Worth Now?
Home values have rapidly increased in recent years. How much is your current home worth now? Get a ballpark estimate from HomeLight’s free Home Value Estimator.
Understanding home equity investment
Home equity investment is a financial arrangement where, instead of borrowing against your home’s equity, you partner with an investment company. In this partnership, the company provides you with a lump sum of cash in exchange for a percentage of your home’s future value. This is notably different from traditional home equity loans or home equity lines of credit (HELOCs), where you borrow money and pay it back with interest.
The key aspect of HEI is that it’s not a loan. There are no monthly payments or interest rates. Instead, when you decide to sell your home, or at the end of the agreed term (usually 10 to 30 years), the company receives its share of the home’s appreciated value along with the original investment. This can be particularly beneficial if you’re seeking immediate liquidity but are not in a position to handle additional monthly payments.
HEIs are especially attractive to homeowners who have significant equity in their homes but might struggle to secure traditional loans. Let’s look at some specific situations where an HEI might be helpful. We’ll also provide a dollar-amount example later in this post.
Why homeowners choose home equity investments
Homeowners are increasingly turning to home equity investments (HEIs) as a viable alternative to customary borrowing methods for several compelling reasons. Here’s why:
- Avoiding high interest rates and closing costs: Traditional home equity loans and lines of credit come with interest rates and closing costs that can significantly increase the overall repayment amount. HEIs, on the other hand, do not have these additional costs, making them a more economical option in the long run.
- Overcoming credit challenges: For homeowners with low credit scores or a less-than-ideal credit history, securing a traditional loan can be challenging. HEIs offer a solution as they focus more on the home’s equity value rather than the individual’s creditworthiness.
- High debt-to-income ratio: Traditional lenders often shy away from borrowers with high debt-to-income ratios. HEIs provide an alternative for homeowners who may not qualify for traditional loans due to this financial metric.
- Solutions for the self-employed: Self-employed individuals often face hurdles in proving consistent income, a requirement for traditional loans. HEIs cater to this group by offering a more flexible qualification process based on home equity rather than income verification.
- House-rich, cash-poor dilemma: Many homeowners have built substantial equity in their homes over time but lack liquid assets. HEIs allow these homeowners to convert part of their equity into cash, providing financial relief without the need for monthly loan repayments.
These factors make home equity investments an attractive option for a wide range of homeowners, especially those looking for financial flexibility and those who may not fit the traditional lending mold. In the next section, we’ll unravel how HEIs work so you’ll know what strings are attached — some can be binding and others liberating.
How home equity investments work
Home equity investments provide a unique way for homeowners to access cash by selling a portion of their home’s future value. Here’s a step-by-step explanation, followed by an illustrative example:
- Agreement with an investment company: Homeowners enter into a contract with an investment company, selling a stake in their home’s future value in exchange for a lump sum of cash now.
- No monthly payments: Unlike a loan, there are no monthly payments. The homeowner continues to own and live in their home.
- Settlement at the end of the term: At the end of the agreed term (10 years, for example) or when the home is sold, the investment company receives a percentage of the home’s appreciated value.
Home equity investment example
Let’s look at an example of how a home equity investment would work. For clarity, we’ll use a $300,000 home value. This could be how much your paid-off home is worth, or how much equity stake you own in the property.
If an investment company buys a 20% stake in your home equity and your home is worth $300,000, it would give you a $60,000 lump sum.
- Your home’s current value: $300,000
- Amount of cash you need: $60,000
- Investment company’s stake: 20%
- HEI contract term: 10 years
- Home’s annual appreciation rate: 3%
At the end of 10 years, the home appreciates to approximately $403,175. The homeowner will need to pay back the original investment ($60,000) plus the investor’s 20% stake in the home’s appreciation ($20,635). In this case, the payback amount would be about $80,635.
Below is a table that shows the breakdown of this HEI scenario, and what happens if, for some reason, the home depreciates in value — since it is an investment venture, after all.
| If your home appreciates | If your home depreciates | |
| Starting home value | $300,000 | $300,000 |
| Home value at repayment | $403,175 | $280,000 |
| Total increase/decrease | $103,175 | -$20,000 |
| Shared equity percentage | 20% (gain of $20,635) | 20% (loss of $20,000) |
| Original funding amount | $60,000 | $60,000 |
| Amount you owe the investor | $80,635 | $40,000 |
What if your home depreciates?
In cases where the home’s value depreciates, the investment company also shares in the financial loss. As you can see in the table above, at the end of the 10 years, the amount you owe can be less than the amount you would have owed had the property retained the same value or grew in value throughout the term. This shared risk makes HEIs a collaborative investment between the homeowner and the investment company.
Pros and cons of home equity investments
While home equity investments offer an innovative way to access funds, it’s important to weigh their advantages and disadvantages to determine if it’s a good choice for your situation.
Pros
- No monthly payments: One of the most significant benefits of HEIs is the absence of monthly repayments, easing the financial burden on homeowners.
- Access to cash without high interest: HEIs provide immediate liquidity without the high interest rates associated with traditional loans.
- Flexible qualification criteria: These investments are often more accessible to those with credit challenges, high debt-to-income ratios, or irregular income, such as self-employed individuals. Unlike a loan, there are no minimum income requirements.
- Can be a fast process: With an HEI, it’s your home, not you, that must qualify for the approved investment. With established equity and a positive appreciation history, completing the process can be faster than applying for and receiving a loan.
- Shared risk in property value fluctuations: Unlike traditional loans, the investment company shares in both the gains and losses of the home’s value over the term.
Cons
- Reduced profit from home appreciation: By sharing a portion of your home’s future value, you may receive less from the sale of your home than if you had not engaged in an HEI.
- You must have sufficient equity: You typically need a substantial amount of equity in your home in order to enter into a home equity investment agreement.
- Complexity: HEIs can be more complex than traditional loans. For example, the service you choose may offer several types of investment options, such as equity-only or appreciation-only sharing agreements.
- Limited availability: Your existing mortgage provider or state laws may restrict you from entering into a home equity investment agreement.
- Impact on future property sales: The agreement with the investment company could affect your flexibility in selling or refinancing your property in the future. HEIs can introduce a risky set of possible outcomes.
- Potential for higher total cost: If your home appreciates significantly, the amount repaid to the investment company could exceed what you might have paid in interest on a traditional loan.
Overcoming the HEI total cost drawback
The final cost on the payback day of reckoning is often the biggest concern homeowners have when considering a home equity investment agreement. Depending on appreciation rates, what you pay back to the investment company at the end of the term could be two or three times higher than the amount the HEI company originally gave you. To counter this concern, many companies will include a cap in the contract that sets a limit on the annual appreciation the investor can earn. You’ll want to avoid an uncapped agreement.
Should you take out a home equity investment?
Before you decide on a home equity investment (HEI), it’s vital to consider several factors to ensure it aligns with your financial situation and goals. In addition to the points we’ve discussed above, here are 10 key aspects to consider before choosing a HEI:
- Existing mortgage constraints: If you have a mortgage, check your loan agreement for any restrictions or penalties related to HEIs. Some lenders may impose fines or even require immediate full repayment of the loan balance (known as an acceleration clause) upon entering into an HEI.
- Consultation with a financial advisor: Given the complexities and potential implications of your existing mortgage, consulting with a financial advisor is a prudent step before proceeding with an HEI.
- Partial buy-out payments: Inquire if the HEI company allows for partial buy-out payments. This option can offer more flexibility by enabling you to spread out your repayment over time, rather than a lump sum at the end of the term.
- Maximum repayment cap: Carefully read the HEI contract to check if there’s a cap on the final payback amount. This cap can protect you from exorbitant repayments if your home appreciably increases in value.
- Repayment inability: Be aware of the consequences if you’re unable to repay the HEI investors. In some cases, this might lead to the forced sale of your home to cover the debt.
- Long-term financial goals: Consider how an HEI fits with your long-term financial plans. While it provides short-term liquidity, it may impact your net proceeds from a future home sale.
- Market conditions: Real estate market trends can affect your home’s future value and consequently the amount you’ll owe. A rising market may increase your repayment amount, while a declining market might reduce it.
- Tax implications: HEIs can have different tax implications compared to traditional loans. Consult a tax advisor to understand how an HEI might affect your tax situation.
- Contract terms and conditions: Every HEI agreement is unique. Pay close attention to the details, including the percentage of equity the company will hold, the term length, and any other specific conditions.
- If a homeowner dies: If the homeowner passes away — and the property goes to an estate — the estate must honor the terms of the HEI agreement. Any heirs will need to divide the proceeds from any gains or share in any losses.
Making an informed decision on a home equity investment requires a thorough evaluation of these factors. It’s essential to fully understand the implications, both immediate and long-term, before committing to this financial strategy.
How to get started with a home equity investment
Initiating a home equity investment (HEI) is a straightforward process. Here’s how to get started:
- Evaluate your financial status: Begin by assessing your home’s current equity and your overall financial goals. This initial step is important to determine if an HEI is suitable for your needs.
- Research HEI providers: Investigate different HEI companies, focusing on their terms, customer feedback, and transparency. Check customer reviews, testimonials, and any history of disputes or legal issues.
- Prepare documentation: Gather necessary documents such as proof of home ownership, current mortgage details, and any other relevant financial information. This preparation will streamline the application process.
- Apply for the HEI: With your chosen provider and all necessary documentation in hand, proceed with the HEI application. This step typically involves a property valuation (appraisal) and a review of your financial situation by the HEI company.
- The company makes an offer: The HEI company will work with you to finalize an offer. If accepted, you sign a contract and receive the agreed-upon lump-sum cash payment.
Should I use a home equity investment solution?
Home equity investments are not a one-size-fits-all solution. Deciding whether an HEI is right for you requires careful consideration of various factors. It’s a decision that hinges not just on immediate financial needs but also on long-term plans and the potential impact on your home’s equity.
As you weigh your options, think about how an HEI fits into your broader financial picture. Consider these questions:
- Will entering into an HEI agreement align with my family’s goals?
- Am I planning on staying in this home for the life of the HEI term?
- How might market fluctuations affect the outcome I’m hoping for?
- Am I comfortable with the shared risk and reward model that an HEI entails?
Home equity investments represent a significant and innovative financial decision. HomeLight recommends you discuss this option with a qualified financial advisor before entering into an HEI agreement. By thoroughly evaluating the pros and cons, understanding the contractual details, and considering your financial trajectory, you can make an informed choice that best suits your needs and circumstances.
Editor’s note: This post is for educational purposes, not financial advice. If you are considering a home equity investment agreement, HomeLight encourages you to reach out to your own advisor.
Header Image Source: (Sieuwert Otterloo / Unsplash)
At HomeLight, our vision is a world where every real estate transaction is simple, certain, and satisfying. Therefore, we promote strict editorial integrity in each of our posts.